Activists Collapse Radome at ECHELON Intercept Facility in New Zealand
April 30th, 2008First, a technical point.
The Director of the Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB), Air Marshal Bruce Ferguson, said that the purpose of the radomes is simply to protect the dishes from the weather. This statement is a lie by omission.
If the azimuth and elevation of a surveillance dish are known, the satellite that is under surveillance can be determined in a matter of seconds. Radomes are placed over satellite dishes to prevent observation of these data points. And yes, to protect them from harsh weather.
Now, a quick look at the political side.
There’s a lot of self-congratulatory silliness going on in activist circles right now.
Here’s a question for everyone who’s impressed by the popping-the-radome story:
Which country is New Zealand’s number two trading partner (Australia is #1)?
According to Statistics New Zealand, the answer is the United States of America.
With a statistic of that magnitude hanging over the land, these antics in Waihopai seem like a lot of folly to me.
Most—not all—political activism, focuses on symbols, abstractions, while the relevant and painful points remain behind the scenes. Guys, look at the underlying economic relationships between corrupt politicians and the corporations. That’s the smelly, messy stuff. Getting people to think differently about economic assumptions is the way to free New Zealand from the foreign entanglements that are becoming increasingly costly for our country.
That said, GE crops still aren’t allowed in New Zealand; neither is nuclear power. The credit for those miracles must go to the activists.
Via: New Zealand Herald:
Prime Minister Helen Clark has condemned this morning’s attack on the ‘spy base’ at Waihopai as “senseless”.
Three protesters have been arrested after invading the base and puncturing one of the large white domes that house two satellite dishes.
Adrian Leason, Sam Land and Dominican friar Peter Murnane are due to appear in Blenheim District court this afternoon.
Questioned in Auckland this morning, Helen Clark would not put an estimate on the cost of the attack but said Air Marshal Ferguson was travelling to Marlborough today to make an assessment.
“Obviously it’s just imposing a cost on the taxpayer having to rebuild. That’s why I describe it as a senseless act of criminal vandalism”.
Asked if any information had been lost in the security breach, she said she never commented on security matters.
“Our focus today is on the steps we’re going to take to support the police with the criminal investigation and to start repairing the damage.”
Helen Clark said the Government had received no comment from other countries regarding the breach.
Opponents of the Waihopai base argue that it is primarily feeding information to the United States in support of wars New Zealanders do not support.
But the secretive Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB), which operates the base, near Blenheim, rejects this.
The protesters’ spokesman, Manu Caddie, spoke to nzherald.co.nz from Waihopai.
He said all three protesters had been arrested after cutting through three fences – one of which had razor wire – and using sickles to deflate the kevlar dome structure.
Mr Caddie estimated the group could have caused $30,000 worth of damage during the protest, which was against the US-led “war on terror”.
“We are drawing attention to the issue, particularly in an election year and encouraging New Zealanders to have a debate about whether they want to be funding this kind of activity in their backyard,” Mr Caddie said.
Air Marshal Ferguson said today the security breach was of grave concern.
“Naturally, this is a very serious breach and it’s one of the reasons I’m here – to look at that, and initiate an inquiry into how this in fact occurred so we can put in place further preventative measures,” he told Radio New Zealand
Air Marshal Ferguson said it was obvious the men had penetrated three fences before deflating the dome but it was unclear how other security devices failed to detect the intrusion.
Alarms did activate but CCTV footage was no help due to heavy fog, he said.
The domes, made of a rubberised material, acted purely as a “waterproof jacket” to protect the antennae from adverse weather, he said.
“We’re trying to protect them for longevity.”
He said there was some protest action at the base over the weekend but it was not known if it was linked to today’s attack.
Mr Caddie said there were direct parallels between the Roman Empire and modern day America. He said the group, which called themselves the Ploughshares, followed Jesus’ example of resisting power on an ethical basis.
Mr Caddie told NZPA news agency the action took about two months to plan and the group did not really expect to succeed.
“We were expecting not to get anywhere close to it.”
The planning involved a lot of texting, emails and phone calls, which were not intercepted, he said.
“I guess it shows that the system doesn’t work that well.”
He said the three protesters who had been arrested hoped not to go to jail, but were prepared for it.
A statement by the group from their website said: “Our group, including a Dominican Priest, temporarily closed the base by padlocking the gates and proceeded to deflate one of the large domes covering two satellite dishes.
“At 6am we cut through three security fences surrounding the domes – these are armed with razor wire, infrared motion sensors and a high voltage electrified fence.
“Once inside we used sickles to cut one of the two 30-metre white domes, built a shrine and knelt in prayer to remember the people killed by United States military activity.”
The group said that it had financed its activities through “personal savings, additional part-time employment and a small interest-free loan from one of our supporters”.
In its justification for the attack, the group said it was responding to the Bush administration claim that intelligence gathering was the single most important tool in the “so-called war on terror” and that Waihopai was a part of that.
“This war will have no end until citizens of the world refuse to let it continue.”
It said that it had carried out the attack in the name of the “Prince of Peace”. The website contains Christian references to the Bible.
One of the protesters is Father Peter Murnane from the Dominican Priory in Auckland.
Father Chris Loughnan, who lives with Father Peter, said he was unaware of any arrests.
He said he was also unaware of the protest but it didn’t surprise him.
“It’s about New Zealand’s passive cooperation in war mongering. The information obtained at Waihopai is used in military intelligence,” Father Chris said.
Green Party foreign affairs spokesman Keith Locke said the party would be calling for a public debate and information on the cost and the purpose of the Waihopai base if it was part of the next government.
Mr Locke said the US spy base effectively compromised New Zealand’s independent foreign policy.
He said he had previously asked the Government for a breakdown of the GCSB’s budget but was refused. Mr Locke said the true cost of the spy base to New Zealanders was not known.
The intelligence game
* The secretive Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) collects “intelligence” on New Zealand’s behalf, and is responsible for guarding the country’s secret information.
* Its budget for the current financial year is $39.288 million and it employs about 370 staff.
* The GCSB’s head office is in Wellington and it operates intelligence-gathering posts at Waihopai, in Marlborough, and at Tangimoana, near Bulls
As always with a piece of activism it’s now all about who can get the best PR out of it – no doubt the powers that be will attempt to show how there are people who support terrorists in New Zealand but on the other hand the sheer power of a photo of Waihopai with it’s bubble burst is pretty good. It makes for a great image and the ability to help publicise the activist’s point of view.
The fact that the activists are priests helps their PR a little better too – but personally I think if they’d popped both and then erected a giant mickey mouse balloon over one of them that would have been much more powerful because the public would have found it hard to believe they are terrorist sympathisers when they appear to be poking fun.
I think I’ve heard of one of these priests before – If it’s who I think it is he once went to the US embassy, slit his wrists and smeared blood all over their carpet to protest the war in Iraq. That’s impressive commitment to the cause if nothing else.
This surprised me somewhat as I’d always assumed the domes were rigid.
It was a bit of a silly stunt though, even though I agree that US foreign policy has a fairly high mortality rate among the people they’re claiming to help. I cant help but wonder what actual impact this will have – surely most communication is now via undersea fibre, which is tapped on-location?
I was in NZ last week. Every person I spoke to about this, whether Pakeha, immigrant or Maori, seemed rather pleased to see this bubble being burst.
Reminds me a little of the Chaser team’s penetration of the APEC summit which seemed to cheer up a lot of Aussies. (Heard a story from a Foxtel employee who heard it from one of their news presenters that when the event happened the troll who speaks into their earpieces told them they were not to laugh or communicate the event with any humour and that it was a serious breach of national security and should be presented with appropriate gravity. “Do not laugh!” Ha!)